Are you a meat lover, but can’t seem to find any quality cuts in your local stores? Do you dislike the amount of time that is needed to find just the right piece?

If so, you might like a delivery service such as ButcherBox. They will do all the hard work for you – they will obtain the meat from local farmers, and with minimal processing, ship it frozen right to you. All you need to do is thaw it out and prepare it just the way you like it.

This ButcherBox review will go over the basic aspects of their business, from the quality of their suppliers to the tightness of their packaging.

In the end, you’ll have all the information you need to know whether they’re the right choice for you.

Steaming food tray with lid
Butcher Box Logo

$5.17

Aveg. Meal Price

4.6

4.6/5
butcherbox header image

What is ButcherBox?

They are a meat delivery service that specializes in connecting farmers to customers. Their products are carefully chosen for their health – the beef is grass-fed and free of antibiotics and hormones; the pork is heritage bred; the chicken is free-range.

All that should contribute to the quality of the final product as it is shipped to you. The products are minimally processed, vacuum-sealed, and packaged with dry ice to keep them fresh. And, best of all, when possible, they are sourced from local farmers, which should minimize the amount of time the meat spends traveling, which also reduces the need for preservatives.

Features of ButcherBox

image of butcherbox features

High-Quality Meat

As we’ve mentioned, the meat always comes from high-quality sources. You’ll find no antibiotics or hormones, all the animals were treated as humanely as possible, and they all come from local farms. The animals themselves were kept as healthy as possible, as well.

That, in itself, means that the time spent in transit is minimal, and the processing itself doesn’t use any harmful artificial flavors, colors, or preservatives. All of these factors contribute to the overall quality of the products they ship.

Convenient

Once you receive the package, the meat is ready for further preparation. What you do with it and what you pair it with are completely up to you. They are there, in your freezer, waiting until the day you plan on eating them arrives.

When you need them, you simply thaw them out, finish preparing them, and cook your meal as you see fit. You can order as little or as much as you need, so that way, your fridge won’t be overflowing with meat after several weeks.

Tasty

Because the meat itself comes from high-quality sources, it also tastes better. That means, no more excessive condiments, dips, or dressings to make your steak taste okay; when properly prepared, ButcherBox cuts will be as tasty as anything from a restaurant.

That is actually their greatest advantage – you don’t have to be a chef to prepare a tasty meat-based meal if you’re working with high-quality ingredients. In the end, the difference in quality will be noticeable to anyone.

Flexible Subscription

At the same time, their subscription plans offer plenty of flexibility. You can opt for several different delivery schedules. And, should you need to go on a trip and don’t want the meat going bad on your porch, pausing is quick and easy.

And, if you don’t want to use their services anymore, canceling your subscription is easy. And, should you change your mind at a later date, resuming is as easy as canceling. With this much flexibility, you can adapt their service to your needs and schedule.

Time-Saving

Finding the right cut can be a daunting task. What you’re after might not be always available, and you might need to shop around until you find the perfect piece. That can, in itself, take up way too much of your time.

When using ButcherBox, you avoid these problems. You simply choose the meat you like and have it delivered to you every week. You can alternate and select other pieces you like, too. In the end, you’ll save a massive amount of time you’d otherwise spend shopping.

Organic

They source their meat from local farmers, and they treat their livestock well. The beef is grass-fed and free of hormones and antibiotics, as are the free-range chicken, turkey, and heritage-bred pork.

Despite all that, they still manage to keep their price down, which helps bring organic meat to a wider array of people who might otherwise not bother. While their products still aren’t inexpensive, they are significantly cheaper than what you’d pay if you sought out an alternative.

For more organic food deliveries, check our guide.

image of butcherbox moto

ButcherBox Plan Options

They offer two methods to choose what you want. You could opt for one of their curated boxes, which contain a mix of beef, pork, and chicken, or you could customize the contents of your package yourself, choosing from a wide variety of options.

Both of these come in two sizes, the smaller one is appropriate for singles or couples, while the bigger option is usually meant for families.

That way, you’ll have plenty of choices, regardless of what option you go for.

Who Would Love ButcherBox?

Busy People

Their service is ideal for those who lack the time (top meal kits) to go on an extensive shopping spree to find just the right cut. You could instead leave that to the experts at ButcherBox, and have them deliver that perfect piece right to your door.

Then you can relax and concentrate on your work better, knowing that the meat part of your next meal is taken care of.

Organic Fans

If you live in an area without access to responsively and humanely raised livestock, they can be an ideal solution. They’ll bring you grass-fed beef, heritage-bred pork, and free-range chicken, all at a price that can be comparable to what you’d pay for processed and mass-produced meat at the supermarket.

Try out organic meal kits from our top rated guide to match with the high quality meat.

Want to Cook Own Recipes

Those that want to prepare their own recipes can find their service invaluable. While there are plenty of meal kit delivery services, very few of them focus on the meat itself, and if you want the best piece, you’ll have to look for it.

Protein Lovers

They might be the ideal delivery service for those that simply enjoy animal-based protein. If you’re a meat-lover, you’re sure to find their offer more than enticing. And, for that price, you’ll get the choice cuts, all of which will make a delicious steak once you’re finished with preparation.

Pros and Cons of ButcherBox

Advantages

  • Minimizes Food Wastes – When you fill your freezer with frozen meat and only thaw it out when you plan on eating it, you’ll produce less food waste than if you buy products for that day or if you order takeout.
  • Money-Saving – These products can, in the end, end up being cheaper than takeout. When your fridge is full, you also don’t need to go shopping, which can also end with a lot of impulse-buy items you don’t actually need.
  • Cost-Efficient – While the packages themselves can seem dauntingly expensive, when you prepare your meal, you’ll spend less per serving than what you’d pay in a restaurant. That can bring you considerable savings over time. And, since you don’t need to spend all those hours shopping for the right cut, you can use that spare time to do whatever you like.

Disadvantages

  • Bulky Packaging – To keep the meat frozen during transport, the packaging must be a bit bulkier. After all, apart from the animal protein, it also needs to include packets of dry ice to keep the whole shipment refrigerated. It also uses packaging popcorn to keep it in place, which means that it can have more waste.
  • Damaged Packaging – Some customers have complained that their vacuum-packed meat got punctured in transport. Unfortunately, that can result in it going bad. ButcherBox will not offer refunds for those items, but they will include a replacement in the next shipment.
  • Quantity – This can be a problem if you have an irregular meat-eating schedule. In that case, you’ll find that the box you received has either too much or too little. While you can adjust the size of the package itself, this can still be a problem if you don’t have a strict dietary schedule.

What Is Inside a ButcherBox Meat Delivery?

The exact contents will vary depending on which option you chose. If you opted for their custom box, you’ll find all the items you ordered. If, however, you’d prefer to let them choose for you, one of their curated boxes will usually contain a mix of different kinds of meats.

You’ll usually see anywhere between 8 and 11 pounds of products, most of which will be ground beef, as well as a combination of steaks and bacon. That should be enough meat for 15 to 20 meals. The larger option will contain between 16 and 22 pounds, enough for about 40 meals.

image of butcherbox delivery

How Much Does ButcherBox Subscription Cost?

This varies by which option you choose. The custom box is costlier than the curated box, and both are available in standard and big-box sizes. The curated options will cost you $129 for the classic box and $238 for the larger package.

The custom boxes are a bit bigger, allowing for the extra pound or two. They are, however, more expensive, with the cheaper option costing $149, and the pricier box has a price tag of $270.

Meal plan

  • The custom box
  • The Mixed Box
  • The Beef & Pork Box
  • The Beef & Chicken Box
  • The All Beef Box

Price per box

  • $149 - $270
  • $129 - $238
  • $129 - $238
  • $129 - $238
  • $129 - $238

ButcherBox Delivery Areas

Their shipping covers the contiguous US, with no options to deliver to Hawaii, Alaska, or Canada. They will also cover the costs of shipping, so you don’t have to worry about that.

And, as they use FedEx Home delivery, you don’t need to need to be home for the package to arrive, nor do you need to sign anything. You should note, however, that you shouldn’t leave it out too long, otherwise the dry ice might melt, which could cause the products to go bad.

How to Pause or Cancel Subscription

Both of these are as simple as clicking a button on your account page, with no additional fees required. They allow you to pause for up to six months, and if you don’t want to use their services anymore, canceling is also quick and easy.

You can also adjust the frequency of deliveries should you find that you’re receiving too much.

ButcherBox Customer Service

There are many ways to find answers to your questions. Their Help Center is quite comprehensive, answering the most frequently asked questions.

If you don’t find what you’re looking for there, you can always send them an e-mail, and somebody will contact you with your answers. They also have a live chat option on their website, and you can call their phone number to receive additional help.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it worth it?

While it may seem like their prices are high, especially when compared to grocery stores, ButcherBox can still be worth it in the end. After all, you could spend hours trying to find just the right cut, or you can order a package from them. That will save you time, and you’ll get quality organic meat at the same time.

Does ButcherBox have discount codes?

Yes, they have plenty of discount codes and special promos. After a simple search, you’re sure to find a wide variety of codes, some of which will give you additional meals to your first or next package, while others will provide you with a discount. You should pay attention to the expiry dates, though.

What recipes are great for ButcherBox?

There are so many different recipes that it can be difficult to assess what you could find great or tasty. Fortunately, they have a section of their site dedicated exclusively to recipes that you can make with their products, and you’re sure to find an idea or two there.

Final Thoughts

Even though their prices might seem steep, ButcherBox can still be worth it in the end, especially when you count the hours you’d otherwise spend shopping for the perfect cut.

While their service isn’t perfect, they still try to fix their mistakes, and they will add replacements for any meat that was damaged during shipping. And, when you combine that with the quality of their suppliers and products, these little objections can be insignificant.

They will provide you with plenty of choices, all sourced from local farms who raise their animals responsively and humanely. While that can lead to an increase in price, the difference in quality can be staggering, especially when compared to what you could obtain in your local store.

Related posts: